Відео

China: "We are respecting USA's Wolf Amendment of 2011, that prohibits any collaboration between USA and China" USA: "No, no, no.... Wolf Amendment only applies when it disadvantages China. Just like democracy, human rights, freedom and Rules-Based World Order. Now hand over the damn samples!!"

Geezzz. Can't take this seriously. "Don't Recommend Channel."▼

It has nothing to do with China not sharing Moon samples with USA (but is sharing with every other country). You forgot to mention "The Wolf Amendment" a law passed by USA's Congress in 2011 that prohibits USA's National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA) from using government funds to engage in direct, bilateral cooperation with the Chinese government and China-affiliated organizations from its activities without explicit

Methodic China's Moon Landings: Chang'e 1 (Orbit the Moon) 200km Luna Obiter above Moon for sending back 120m HiRes Luna surface images (2007) Chang'e 2 (Orbit the Moon) 100km high Lunar Orbiter to determine Landing site (Oct 2010). Chang'e 3 (Land with Rover "Near-side") Lunar Rocket - with Orbiter, Lander, Rover on "Near-side" of the Moon (Dec 2013). Chang'e 4 (Land with Rover "Far-side") First country to do a SOFT LANDING with a Rover on the "Far-side" of the Moon (2018) Chang'e 5 (Return Samples "Near-side") Orbiter, Lander, Rover and Return Module, returns Moon Samples (1,731g) from the "Near-side" of the Moon (2020) Chang'e 6 (Return Samples "Far-side") Orbiter, Lander, Rover and Return Module, returns Moon Samples (1,935.3g) from the "Far-side" of the Moon (June 2024)

What a shame. Didnt the US refused cooperstion with china, denying them in particular any access to their space station. Its not because the US didnt bring back lunar soil thay claimed to have gone to the moon. They hsd never been to the moon.

US is so srrogant thst it has lsws not to cooperate with China. No civil person will coooerate with such arrogant country.

these policies & sanctions are just modern versions of The Chinese Exclusion Act. 1882. the western imperialism nature will be its downfall

It is only fair for this very small limited lunar sample to be shared with only those who have truly cooperated and contributed to China's space program! It would be very unfair to share with those didn't cooperate and didn't contribute!

envious, jealous and hateful

The wolf amandment makes China move forward quickly in the space sector

The reason is the American on-goal laughingly called the Wolf Amendment.

Fake news!

Poor American scientists! NASA should ask its government to abolish the Wolf Amendment for cooperation with China to take place.

Elon Musk will fetch the 2 astronauts home if Boeing is willing to pay 3.5b.

US plays 'blame-shifting' game with China as lunar soil research set to start. US has once again resorted to its "sour grapes" rhetoric upon seeing China's successful retrieval of fresh lunar soils from the far side of the moon, by claiming that China did not directly invite US scientists to participate in the lunar soil research. It has been unfortunate however after the US’s Congressional act adopted in 2011, the US space institutions have been blocked from cooperating with China, which is the Wolf Act. Now, the US make an about-face by accusing and criticised China of being "intolerant of any examination of their space program." Bill Nelson accused China of being inflexible and not very transparent. The US refusal to allows China to participate in space exploration and the US even passed law like the Wolf Amendment in 2011 to banned China from engaging in direct, bilateral cooperation regarding space exploration and scientific experiments. China decided to build its own space project and space station to conduct scientific experiment as the US steadfastly banned China from the space endeavour. The moon samples is fully open to international researchers, and guides for the open solicitation of research proposals will be regularly issued under bilateral cooperation agreements. China’s rock samples is of great scientific value in areas including space weathering, volcanism, the regional geological background and evolution of the moon. The long-term and systematic research on lunar samples including its structure, physical properties, chemical composition, isotopic composition, characteristics of the minerals and the geological evolution will deepen our understanding of the origin and evolution of the moon. China said that there would be three main uses of the samples: science, public outreach and sharing samples with other countries and scientists around the world. China is ready to share the lunar samples including relevant data with all like-minded institutions from other countries. The US is distorting the truth of banning and restricting space cooperation with China by blaming China for not inviting NASA to take part in the moon probe. NASA spokesperson Faith McKie accuse China working with the European Space Agency, France, Italy and Pakistan on the Chang’e 6 mission but NASA didn't get "any direct invitation" to study China's moon rocks, after China welcomed all scientists from around the world to apply to study them. The US side seems to have forgotten to mention its domestic legislation such as the Wolf Amendment. US scientists and institutions are not allowed by US government to participate in cooperation with China. "The existence of the Wolf Amendment has basically shut the door to space collaboration. China's collaboration with international partners is based on equality and mutual benefit, leveraging their respective scientific resources, facilities, and expertise whereas the US only wants what it doesn't have, and its engagement with China would be advantageous only to US itself. NASA chief Bill Nelson keeps making smearing remarks against China's space development with ridiculous and pathetic attempt to hype the "China threat" theory only exposes the US' own hegemonic and colonial ambitions. Nelson's attempt in a way reflects the mentality that the US wants to colonize the moon and consolidate its own hegemony in space with the new space version of an "Enclosure Movement" of the Artemis program, which gathered "like-minded" partners such as Canada, Japan and Europe but excludes China and Russia. Nelson accused China of being "one of the very few nations" that would not be partners with the US and that it is being "very secretive" in terms of space programs. Nelson accused China of lacking needed transparency over issues. The NASA chief blatantly claimed that China is "trying to occupy the moon." and China stole the US' space technology. These accusations are unfounded and unjustified and China has always had a cooperative and open attitude in the space sector. The US should face up to its own problem of overall weakening engineering capability and the lack of long-term planning in its space industry.

US have to grow up and stop acting like a bitch.If you cooperate with China in the first place you would have no problem today.

China should never tempted by the saying that everything collected from the moon belongs to the whole world, because the US never has such righteous announcement before and now.

The United States has historically viewed China with disdain due to its communist government. Under the Wolf Amendment, the U.S. passed legislation to prevent China from becoming a space exploration partner. However, this only served to strengthen China's resolve, much like what happened with Huawei. The company improved significantly despite American sanctions. Now, the focus is on chips and electric vehicles. When will this end? It likely won't, as Washington seems to overlook that for the past decade, China has been producing six to seven times more STEM graduates than the U.S., despite having a population only four times larger. Each year, China produces more STEM graduates than the U.S. and EU combined. How can China be stopped?

Your video is rather dubious, let me put it most courteously. You were spinning the words of cooperation round and round, one way or the other, throughout the entire video, yet you failed to tell people what physically stands as obstacle to genuine cooperation: [1] the Wolf Amendment of 2011. [2] US's flat rejection to China's wish to participate in the building of the so-called International Space Station, ISS. and many other things.

Shame on you, the US...China has its own Space Station and showed the world it's recent moon landing and returned with precious samples from the moon.. NEVER cooperate or share the lunar samples with the ungrateful and arrogant US

no mention of the US' Wolf Amendment. Incomplete.

Hi NASA, if you are interested in moon soil and rocks like the Chinese, why don't you send your astronauts to the moon to collect some? No need to ask China to share with you. It is a disgrace to ask as you refuse to work with China in the beginning.

Simply fake news !

One has to question the United States: Why, after its first lunar landing in 1969 and some lunar rock and soil samples were retrieved, that the other successive 5 trips to the lunar surface only resulted in the same rock collecting expedition and there was no attempt in even building a simple lunar base there? Six very expensive trips which became more like tourist visitations with a few scientific "experiments" carried out there like playing a golf shot. Not what one would call really "moonshaking" event. Did NASA lose its ability to imagine and visualize big things back then? Okay - the first trip there was like Christopher Columbus first landing on the New World. Fair enough. Can't expect too much being done except bringing back some soil and rock samples. However, 5 other trips, mostly to do the SAME thing - collect rocks and soil samples and that's all? They didn't even tried to tow one of the spent rocket booster shells to the moon and simply dropping it onto the surface (remember the moon's lower gravity), turn the material into a primitive "hut"! No wonder NASA began to lose the imagination of the American public as well and so, by the time Apollo 13 came around, Americans were more interested in watching television reruns than in the lunar mission as NASA's budget shrank more and more. Sometimes, bold plans can result in bold budgets provided. When President JFK announced his "we shall go to the moon" many thought he was crazy or maybe a bit insane. However, it was a bold and brassy plan that he has not only made but very well detailed and costed - and it gripped the imagination of the American public (as well as the rest of the world). Deadbeats will always be there to criticize anything and there were deadbeats back then who claim the the money would be better spent on the poor. However, even with NASA's budget cut and slashed, the poor is still there - which shows the fruitless critique against having NASA's "big" budget which was used to actually make life better for all of humankind.

the pronounce of Chang-Eh is incorrect. To pronounce 嫦娥 (cháng é), start with a "cha" sound, like the "cha" in "cha-cha", then add the "ng" sound, cha + ng.

A shameless USA episode of a declining great power..

Repeal the Wolf Amendment and apologise first then China can think about it about cooperating .

maybe due to difference of era?

Why bother with American Lunar Sample ? Just collect what u need from the grounds of Hollywood, central Los Angeles.

Failed to mention about the "wolf" set by us government

Remember the US already been to the moon so they claim. Or was that a lie too. So did these liars forget to collect soil samples?

How can China cooperate with the US military government in exploring the outer space such space stations , when the American passed a law banning China to cooperate with NASA , this only shows how hypocrite and bias the US military govt is . Let the neocons swallows their foolish pride .

Such BS. They can't get their J20 engine working, let alone a mach 5 engine. The only way they can make one is after the US make one, so they can steal it. Lmao 😅

The US is frustrated? It excluded itself from cooperating with China (wolf amendment), now it wants to violate its own law?

The Wolf Amendment prevents NASA from cooperating with China so why on earth would China invite the US. Childish sore losers.

China is too nice. They will.

I trust China 💯% I trust the US 0️⃣ %, but hey that’s just me.

如果中国赠送月球样品给美国会违反美国法律，中国一定会遭受制裁，所以中国人尊重美国的法律不会赠送月球样品给美国。

To US, China is at least 20 - 30 years behind in space tech. Based on this assumption, US manufactured the narrative that China may steal US space technology if there is cooperation. Even then, US failed to land on the moon, not once but twice in 2024. The first mission in January 2024 failed to reach the moon and landed on planet Earth instead. While the second mission in April 2024 used its solar panels as the landing gear, thereby crushing them. For China, all their landers landed perfectly and flawlessly on the moon, not only on the near side but on the far side as well. China also landed flawlessly on planet Mars in its debut. But before that landing, Blinken smeared China blatantly in their Alaska meeting that the Chinese lander could not land on Mars while US already exploring that planet.

"little joe blows Byedung" has Hollywood lunar soil to swap for China's lunar soil.

I would'nt give the us didley squat, because they the us would'nt let China on the Iss. If i was Chins i would tell the us to go take a flying leap at a rolling donut hole, and plus don't forget the us want's to go to war with China because the us can't have another neer peer rival, it should be fairley ovious to every one that the us wants to rule the world, and China and Russis are the only countries in the way,

There is a Wolf Ammendment. It violates US law if China gives sample to NASA. China's scientists will be arrested by the US government.

Boo Hoo it sucks to be you (the U.S.) so sad too bad. You F'd around with China's, space program development and are now finding out, you lose.

Who does the US think they're, hello war monger's world doesn't belong to you

Why did you mention the Wolf Clause or Amendment passed by the yankees will ban any cooperation between the USA and China regarding to aerospace study and communication. Don't confuse your viewers about this fact that the Americans impose on themselves about any cooperation between the two country..

China should not coperate with us their will sabotage u beware

USA lawmakers and politicians can only blame themselves for their current dilemmas since they bar China from NASA's co-operation and the "international" space station. This US law still exist. No reason for China to work with the USA at all now.

America goes out of her way to harm China, yet expects China to share the fruits of Chinese labor and ingenuity. America's mantra: Let us stay ahead of you, help us stay ahead of you, subjugate yourselves to American interests and all will be well.

Tofu dreg jet engine.

The US has not shared with China, especially in the ISS. So, the US has set the character of space collaboration between China and the US. If I remember correctly China DID share moon samples last time with the US.